Saturday, June 12, 1999
Protests contain profound message
Every time an important occasion like the reading of the national Budget
in Parliament is disrupted, a profound message is being sent to the government
that the legitimacy of its governance is being seriously questioned. It
has now happened three times in a row in this country, and with each instance,
the gravity of the message has deepened.
In 1997, Mr Musalia Mudavadi was virtually unable to read the
budget over the din and chaos in the House sparked by controversy over
the pace of constitutional and administrative reforms which were to precede
that year's General Election. Irate MPs almost did the unthinkable - lift
the mace from its traditional resting place and walk away with it, hence
taking away the symbolic authority of Parliament.
Last year, it was Mr Simeon Nyachae's turn to suffer the indignity
of having his speech disrupted by angry MPs again pushing a case for urgent
constitutional reforms. It ended with Ugenya MP James Orengo being sent
out and a host of others who supported him.
Mr Francis Masakhalia was this year not spared either although
the disturbance was not as great as in the past years. The issue this time
was anger that parliamentarians could sit there in the elegant ambience
of the House listening to a fairly pompous delivery of a Budget many think
is a waste of time while policemen battered and tear-gassed Kenyans who
were protesting at the plan to return the constitutional review process
to Parliament.
It was an understandable request which, as in the past instances,
fell on deaf ears. It was brushed aside as being out of order and place.
This may be technically true but morally and philosophically dishonest.
The concerns being raised every day by the public, the media, religious
leaders and civic society cannot be isolated at all from the business of
the House.
The fundamental message really is that the irony of pretence -
that it is business as usual in the House - is now unbearable for many
of the MPs inside Parliament and for hundreds of thousands of Kenyans outside.
The government is being told that the people's patience is running out,
and more importantly, that they are ready to risk pain and injury to bring
about change. Commands of order in the House may soon be overtaken by the
reality of disorder outside and, we fear, the government no longer cares.
Comments\Views
about this article