Monday,
June 10, 2002
Obure's Tightrope: Will CKRC
Have to Go?
By PETER MUNAITA
THE EASTAFRICAN
Kenya Finance Minister Chris
Obure walks a tightrope this week when he reads the budget on Thursday
June 13, with poverty alleviation, economic stability and regional integration
top on the agenda.
Mr Obure faces tough choices
in trying to balance a budget excluding funding from donors who, sources
said, had not been involved in the budget-making process this year.
Mr Obure had earlier said
that he would not include external funds, pointing to the breakdown in
relations between the government and the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
Without IMF support, there
is little hope of other donors and investors supporting the economic blueprint,
since they take the Fund's involvement as a green-light to do business
with a country.
With Kenya's budget deficit
at Ksh13.3 billion ($1.7 billion) or 1.6 per cent of the gross domestic
product at the end of March, compared with Ksh11.2 billion ($1.4 billion)
at the same time last year, Mr Obure is faced with three alternatives.
He can either raise taxes; resort to increased domestic borrowing; or expand
the tax net. "Either of these options will result in great harm to an already
crippled economy,"J. K. Njiraini, the Chief Executive of the Institute
of Certified Public Accountants of Kenya (ICPAK) said.
Should he choose to have
a balanced budget, vital projects as well as political expenditures, such
as on the constitutional review, would have to be cut back.
Analysts consider a balanced
budget policy prudent given the hiccups experienced with donors over the
last decade. The Federation of Kenya Employers, an influential lobby on
policy matters, has requested that a task force comprising private sector
representatives be set up to ensure donor assistance is fully utilised.
Although Kenya still craves
donor aid, FKE estimates that about Ksh103 billion ($1.32 billion) of committed
external resources have not been utilised because of the slow rate of implementing
government projects. The failed disbursements in most cases have been the
cause of growing budget deficits that push the government into the domestic
money market.
With the need to reduce domestic
borrowing from the current level of Ksh220 billion ($2.82 billion), increased
resort to the domestic market is the last thing the minister would wants,
more so given the need to stimulate the economy through lower interest
rates. Increasing taxes would also be politically suicidal in an election
year. Key lobby groups have recommended that taxes be reduced across the
board with import duties on inputs for agricultural and industrial production
being abolished.
That leaves Mr Obure with
a task that many of his predeccessors have failed to accomplish widening
the tax net and sealing loopholes for tax evasion without increasing administration
costs. The informal sector, which remains the only sector that is virtually
untaxed in Kenya, presents an ingenuous finance minister with substantial
revenue growth opportunities.
The sector however is extremely
disorganised, to the extent that bringing it under the tax net would involve
more sweat than gain. Last year, it employed 4.6 million people whose engagements
are unregulated and therefore difficult to include in the tax net.
Although Mr Obure will try
to ensnare a few informal activities, improved tax administration coupled
with drastic expenditure cuts seem the key fiscal measures that he will
rely on to balance the budget. And that will not be made easy by high levels
of corruption in and out of the civil service.
A last resort for the government
would be its overdraft facility at the Central Bank. In law, the government
cannot borrow more than five per cent of its last audited revenue, meaning
it can only borrow about Ksh8 billion ($102 million).