Monday, March 12, 2001
KCB Sale Put on Hold as Losses Fall
A JOINT REPORT
THE EASTAFRICAN
THE PLANNED sale of the government's stake in the Kenya Commercial Bank
to a strategic investor has been suspended.
Treasury Permanent Secretary Mr Martin Oduor-Otieno told The EastAfrican
that the sale of a 35 per cent stake in KCB had been "put on hold for a
while" to assess the impact of an ongoing restructuring exercise spearheaded
by the managing director Mr Gareth George.
"The government will realise better value from the sale after the rationalisation,"
Mr Oduor-Otieno explained, saying it was uncertain how long the deal would
remain "on hold." Last week, the managing director of Shah Munge and Partners
stockbrokers, Mr Arthur Namu, argued that the sale should be put off for
at least a year, since the bank's performance had improved in the past
one year.
Audited results for last year showed a loss before tax of Ksh795 million
($9 million), an improvement from the Ksh2.2 billion ($25 million) loss
incurred the previous year. At the Nairobi Stock Exchange, the bank's shares
were trading at Ksh27 ($0.34) last week, and financial analysts predict
a price of Ksh65 ($0.83) per share if the bad debt problem and huge payroll
costs are done away with.
The postponement of the KCB sale, for which advertisements for a transaction
advisor had already been placed in the local press, comes soon after the
government announced that Telkom Kenya's tie-up to a strategic partner
would be delayed by at least two months to allow for negotiations on price.
The postponement of KCB and Telkom Kenya's sale is said to have been
discussed with the World Bank and the IMF when the heads of the two institutions,
Mr James Wolfenson and Mr Horst Koehler paid a courtesy call on President
Daniel arap Moi two weeks ago.
However, during a press briefing in Washington, the director of the
IMF's African Department, Mr Goodall Gondwe, insisted that the Telkom Kenya
sale had to be completed before the IMF released $28 million in disbursements.
The Telkom sale is considered important as a showcase of Kenya's commitment
to a transparent divestiture exercise and is seen as the least problematic
of the conditionalities.
The funds have been "locked" since December following the government's
failure to reconstitute the Kenya Anti-Corruption Authority (Kaca) as an
effective anti-corruption watchdog. Other points of conflict include its
failure to enact an Economic Crimes Bill and a Code of Ethics for civil
servants in the three arms of government – judiciary, executive and parliament.
The IMF's position is that disbursements will not resume until these bills
are passed.
Although parliament is set to resume next week, its rigid timetable
means the crucial Bills are likely to be passed in mid May at the earliest
before parliament goes for a three-week recess. Telkom sale is also likely
to be through around that time.
Assuming the Bills are passed then and the IMF is given a one month's
lead time to assess their effectiveness, the earliest aid disbursements
can resume is July.
If agreement is reached to restart the disbursements, the IMF would
release $28 million comprising $8 million that was to be released in December
and another $20 due now. Should an agreement be delayed until July, the
amount will increase to $72 million since a tranche of $43 million is due
in June.
The IMF had only released $43 million of the $250 million intended for
economic and drought assistance under a poverty reduction and growth facility
running up to 2003 before the programme went "off-track". The World Bank
is also holding $100 million and other lenders some $150 million, although
a $300 million debt rescheduling programme, including $157 million in payments
due this year, is not affected.
An IMF mission is already in Nairobi, led by Mr Menachem Katz, who has
replaced Mr Jose Fajgenbaum as senior advisor on Kenya. The team will gauge
the status of the Bills and assess Kenya's fiscal policy with special scrutiny
given to both the current and next year's budget.
*Reported by Peter Munaita in Nairobi and Kevin J . Kelley in Washington