Monday, April 22,
2002
Three electoral systems in world democracies
By ROBERT ODUOL
There are principally three
basic types of electoral systems: the single-member constituency (first-past-post),
the proportional representation electoral system also known as the List
Proportional or some combination of the two – the mixed systems.
Kenya, like most other former
British colonies, adopted the constituency-based single-member (also referred
to as the first-past-the-post) electoral system at independence and has
retained it ever since.
Currently the country has
210 constituencies each represented in parliament by a single MP elected
on a one-man-one vote basis.
The constituency-based electoral
system differs from the list proportional representation or simply PR electoral
system where political parties draw up lists of those they want in parliament
with the number of seats allocated to each party from the parties' list
on the basis of the proportion of votes each party obtains. Thus the vote
votes, not for the individual candidate but for the party list.
The proportional representation
electoral system is used in most of the smaller European countries like
Netherlands, many Latin American countries, South Africa and Namibia.
South Africa has a two-tier
system where half the seats are voted for through a national vote while
the other half are allocated proportionately on a province-by-province
basis.
Under the proportional representation
system, parties draw up lists of those they want to go to parliament.
The party bosses rank these
and the number of seats each one gets is determined by the proportion of
votes each of the parties receive.
Countries that use PR believe
it is fairer and helps bring women, experts and representatives of special
racial minorities into parliament.
Proportional representation
also helps ensure that small, fringe parties are represented in parliament.
Critics, however, contend
that PR puts too much power in the hands of party bosses.
They say that since there
are no constituencies where the PR electoral system is practised, the voters
do not have a representative. therefore they hardly ever see "their MP".
this is especially true of the average voters in the rural areas.
There are several variations
of proportional representation and semi PR: list PR where seats are allocated
to parties on the basis of their total national vote; semi-PR or "parallel"
system where half or some portion of seats are elected from single member
constituencies and the remainder allocated to parties on the basis of their
total national vote (also known as "hybrid" system).
There is also the mixed member
proportional system where half or some portion of seats are elected from
single member constituencies and the remainder allocated to parties to
achieve the same allocations as would occur under list PR, that is, to
achieve results that are highly proportional overall.
Germany, Lesotho and South
Africa all use this method. The important point is to present the three
main systems i.e single member constituency system, pure PR and the mixed
system