Monday, June 17,
2002
Kenya Election: Where are the Opinion Polls?
By ROBERT ODUOL
Kenya is this year bracing
for a change of its top leadership in elections that are held once every
five years.
The country may also have
a new constitution in place, views on what the people want included in
the document are being collected and collated.
Elsewhere in the world, that
would be the perfect recipe for public opinion polls over who will succeed
the incumbent president and what the public thinks of them.
By this time, someone would
have already zeroed in on the ruling Kenya African National Union's likely
performance in the forthcoming polls and compared this to the past two
multiparty elections. Based on these opinions, predictions would have been
rolling out by the minute.
Yet, with probably only six
months to go before the elections, none of these activities taking place.
Parliamentary candidates are basing their confidence on reassurances from
their supporters.
The more experienced hands
are counting on other factors, such as the size of their clans and wallets,
or simply party affiliation, to see them through.
Public opinion polls, which
are popular in the West as an alternative for participating in decision-making
and forecasting behaviour, have not gained widespread acceptance in developing
countries.
And for the few who even
give it a moment's thought, an opinion poll is essentially viewed as a
way to draw public attention and influence public perceptions.
Not that the public is solely
to blame for this state of affairs. The misconception about the real purpose
of opinion polls may also have come about due to the haphazard and unreliable
polls that have been carried out in recent years.
Shortly after Kenya reverted
to multiparty politics in December 1991, a number of hurriedly conducted
"polls" appeared in several local magazines, ostensibly to determine the
most popular presidential aspirant.
Two groups, one linked to
conservationist Prof Wangari Maathai, called the Middle-Ground Group (MGG),
and another linked to the National Election Monitoring Unit – an umbrella
for several election monitoring groups – also held their own polls.
But unlike the polls in developed
countries, which are often reliable and indicative of voting trends, many
of the Kenyan "polls" were arbitrary and differed significantly in their
forecasts.
In fact, so different were
their findings that even with a fortnight to go to the elections, no one
could rely on them to predict the outcome of that year's election.
A major flaw in these pre-1992
opinion polls was their outright bias for particular candidates and mischievous
disregard for universally accepted research methods.
Their projections, too, were
subjective and unreliable. Unable to rely on them, many people and organisations
opted instead for crude methods like observing the turnout at rallies to
determine the popularity of candidates.
The MGG, for instance, conducted
a "poll" in Nairobi to identify the most popular opposition candidate to
take on the incumbent, President Daniel arap Moi.
But prior to the "polls,"
MGG members had loudly voiced their desire for opposition parties to field
the late Oginga Odinga, who was running on the ticket of the Ford-Kenya
party. Predictably, Odinga easily emerged as the "most popular" in the
MGG polls. A decade later, this perception has hardly changed.
Opinion polls are simply
a picture in time, the static measure of a dynamic entity. A proper poll
must therefore first identify target respondents based on issues to be
investigated.
It must have a properly developed
sample frame and appropriate sample sizes if the margins of error are to
be acceptable.
Kenya has gone through several
developmental phases since independence 40 years ago.
Factors like the rapid development
in news gathering and communication technologies and a growing civic awareness
have also served immensely to weaken government control over the media
and, in turn, opinion polls have flourished.
The result of all this is
that issues like corruption, land, security, economic growth and the environment
have moved to the forefront of political debate.
But if the frequency of opinion
polls has changed radically over the years, perceptions have not.
Nor has the accompanying
civic awareness brought about by these polls changed the public's way of
viewing issues.
Kenyans still consider personality
and location to be of more importance in candidates and party preference
than economic or social issues per se.
The result? Even the most
scientific of opinion polls are not of much use.