Monday, April 15,
2002
A strange election-strike linkage
By WAMBUA SAMMY
A crisis is gathering pace
in Kenya as a series of strikes and protests bring to the fore the effects
of the nation's dwindling economy and administrative ineptitude.
Now that the economic reality
can no longer be overshadowed by politics, 2002 looks set to be an annis
horribilis for the government. Air traffic controllers are on strike over
a pay dispute and teachers are threatening to take similar action. Maize
farmers have rejected a weird barter payment deal suggested by the National
Cereals and Produce Board for their grain harvest. This is all happening
in an election year.
But it is the teachers' strike
that the government takes most seriously. The teachers are to down tools
by June 30 unless the government implements the remaining phases of a 1997
pay deal with the giant Kenya National Union of Teachers (Knut) by April
30.
The 1997 agreement was reached
after an 11-day nationwide teachers' strike in October 1997, which paralysed
learning and examinations. Teachers resumed teaching after the government
agreed to their demand for a 150-200 per cent pay rise in four phases,
the last one being this year. However, only the first phase – involving
35 and 45 per cent respectively – was implemented in 1998. That alone pushed
the annual wage bill from Ksh23.5 billion ($294 million) to Ksh34.6 billion
($432.5 million)
Now, as the clock ticks towards
the June 30 deadline, Education Minister Mr Henry Kosgey is already rubbing
the teachers the wrong way. On April 3, he told parliament that that government
had no money to pay the teachers.
Courting further disaster
last week, the minister unilaterally appointed a 10-member committee –
comprising five government and five Knut officials – without first consulting
with the trade union, ostensibly to renegotiate the 1997 pay deal.
The indignation was predictable
as Knut, on Wednesday, refused to take part in the review. The minister,
said Knut secretary-general Mr Francis Ng'ang'a, was "required to ask for
nominations from the union, but not to appoint them without consultation."
Matters were not made any
better for the government when the Kenya National Association of Parents
supported the planned strike, saying the government should have no problem
in paying the teachers the Ksh20 billion ($250 million) from its Ksh268
billion (3.43 billion) annual income. [The government's figure for the
wage bill is Ksh48 billion ($600 million).
The strike by air traffic
controllers is now in its third week. They are demanding to be delinked
from the civil service and a hefty pay hike to at least Ksh100,000 ($1,250)
from the current Ksh7,500 ($94). No planes are flying into and out of Moi
International Airport, Mombasa at night, while flights to Kisumu, Eldoret
and Lokichoggio airports have been suspended. Airlines are also complaining
of losses because they have to use extra fuel to circle the airports in
view of landing delays, paying workers for extra shifts, refunds for cancelled
flights and hotel bills for stranded passengers. Kenya's tourism,
which has been recovering from a slump, is taking a bad hit from the aviation
strike.
Nevertheless, 14 of the strikers
were arrested on April 13, and charged in court for holding an illegal
assembly. They were also ordered to vacate government houses. The same
day, the government published a Bill setting up the Kenya Civil Aviation
Authority to be responsible for the licensing of air services and the employment
of air traffic controllers, among others. This being one of the key demands
by the striking workers, it would appear that the government adopted a
policy of giving in to their demands, but ensuring that the benefits are
reaped by a different lot as the fate of the sacked 76 and the suspended
192 remains unclear.
This became clear on April
6 when President Daniel Moi invited retired air traffic controllers from
the civil service, private sector and the military to seek employment with
the Directorate of Civil Aviation. Civil aviators say the Civil Aviation
Act requires that air navigation officers who have been out of duty for
at least 20 days be retrained and that the ones being hired by the government
were working illegally because they are not licensed.
Last Wednesday, the Kenya
Pilots Association declared Kenya's airspace unsafe. The use of "few and
tired workers" to man air controls, said the association's secretary general
Mr Gakweli Warrakah, was "a recipe for air disaster." But Permanent Secretary
for Transport Mr Sammy Kyungu declared the Kenyan airspace as "safe as
ever."
The crisis in the agricultural
sector was triggered by the National Cereals and Produce Board (NCPB),
which offered maize farmers fertilisers, fuel, lubricants and seed instead
of paying them Ksh1.5 billion ($18,750,000) which it owes.
As was expected, the offer
has been rejected. On Wednesday, farmers used commandeered NCPB trucks
and their own tractors and trucks to block the streets of Eldoret, an agricultural
town in western Kenya. Police broke up the protest, the second in a week.
Last month, Agriculture Minister
Dr Bonaya Godana was forced to slap a 60 per cent excise duty on imported
milk and milk products after similar protests by farmers, but not before
admitting that the Treasury had allowed 400 tonnes of powder milk into
the country against his advice. That was happening when dairy farmers were
producing seven million litres of milk daily while Kenya's 26 milk processors
can handle a mere 600,000 litres daily.
How the government handles
these mini crises – including others in the sugar sector [where Dr Godana
says he has been forced to publish a faulty Sugar Act] and labour unrest
in the Kenya Railways Corporation and the health sector – will show if
it has the ability to view governance beyond politics.